DF Thoughts on the Met Turandot in HD

Screen Shot 2016-01-30 at 5.33.58 PM

Zeffirelli’s Turandot at the Met — it’s time to put it away

A few thoughts on today’s Turandot, which I saw via HD transmission…

** For years, I’ve been happy that the Met retained the Zeffirelli production, which – for better and worse – exemplifies a kind of opera theatrical style that’s on the fast track to extinction. (I often recommended it – as a show – to theater people wanting a sense of “The Met” in all its grandeur.)

** Watching it today, I thought it’s time to put it away – it looked more than ever like a slightly dilapidated Disneyland attraction, and virtually everything about it – including the disruptive curtain calls after each act, and the endless intermissions – is in the category of Why Some People Hate Opera.

** Certainly not a day of bel canto. Among the principals, only Alexander Tsymbalyuk and Anita Hartig came close what I hoped for, though neither one is Italianate. But at least they have beautiful voices. Hartig especially so – it’s a really gorgeous, round sound, though in today’s performance, she made little of the words, and there’s not a true pianissimo. She’s lovely and sympathetic on the stage, but at times her painting-to-music gestures suggested a Scotto parody. I’d like to hear more of Tsymbalyuk – I like his timbre, and there’s something distinctive and individual in the sound.

** I’d like to hear a lot less of Marco Berti. You know you’re in trouble when you’re nostalgically pining for golden days of late-career Marcello Giordani. Berti’s voice is utterly without tonal allure, and there’s no stylistic or theatrical compensation.

** Nina Stemme is a formidable artist, I think – but Turandot isn’t her thing. I admire the amplitude of her voice, and especially the solidity from bottom to top. But she doesn’t bind the music into meaningful phrases – she pops out high notes in isolation in a way that recalled Birgit Nilsson, but without Nilsson’s astonishing ease and shine. I thought Stemme sounded considerably better after “In questa reggia,” but never to me like a natural Turandot. (And the Met costume, hair, makeup and lighting people did her no favors – in Act II, Stemme resembled Grandmother Burya more than Turandot, and she bore almost no resemblance to the very attractive, animated woman who was interviewed a few weeks ago during the Pecheurs de Perles intermission.)

** I don’t sense there’s a cohesive artistic decision about how to deal with make-up for non-Asian actors in Asian roles. Honestly, I don’t know  what I think is the best way to handle this – but I do think consistency is helpful. (From the still photo of Kristine Opolais costumed for Madama Butterfly, it seems there will be no attempt to make her up for the character – in which case, it’ll be my first time seeing a Cio-Cio-San who looks like Anita Ekberg.)

** May we please have a long break from Renée Fleming channeling Betty Furness? I get that she’s a draw for HD audiences, and that she is generous to contribute her time and support to the Met. (And I wouldn’t wish on anybody – not even a Fox News commentator – the job of interviewing Marco Berti.) But there are people who do this better than Fleming – in a mash-up of interview clips from other HD transmissions, it was Susan Graham who stood out for charm, naturalness and humor. Let’s have more of Graham.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow me on Twitter

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 111 other subscribers

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 111 other subscribers
%d bloggers like this: